Author: J.R.R. Tolkien
Date Finished: 12/04/14
Re-Read? : First time read
Challenges? : Yes – The Classics Club
Overall: 5/5 – absolutely brilliant
I really really enjoyed the first two LOTR books and The Hobbit so I was very excited to get to read this volume these past couple of weeks. I’d managed (somehow) to avoid seeing the films and overhearing people talk about it all my life so I really didn’t know how the story was going to end.
The plot is really good (as always) in this book although maybe slightly weaker than the previous two volumes – I do think I enjoyed this one the least out of all the three. I just felt at times it was just slightly too predictable compared to the other two. Although the ending is slightly anticlimactic, this can’t really be avoided when you have been reading over 1000 pages of build up! Nevertheless I was enthralled by this book, especially in the middle and I definitely wanted to keep turning the pages.
The characters are as phenomenal as before, and it feels like everyone gets their story and part to play in the plot, which is a nice touch. I liked the way slightly more minor characters, like the men in Gondor/Rohan had storylines weaved into the main plot as well. I was a bit gutted we didn’t really get to meet Sauron – I was kind of hoping for a hugely dramatic stand-off between him and Gandalf over the Cracks of Doom…in fact I think this was the area I a bit disappointed in really – that it all ended without one last battle with everyone involved, but hey ho!
I felt like there was slightly more assumption of the history of Middle-Earth in this volume than the others – everything before was always clearly explained (e.g. the histories of the One Ring etc) but some of the facts about “The King” etc were somewhat assumed that we would know; after reading the appendices, of course it all became very clear but at some points some of the formalities and who was actually in charge of who and in what land was a bit confusing!
It seems as though I’ve only commented on the flaws of this book, but that’s not how I see it at all – I have sung Tolkien’s praises so much in my previous posts that I think (so as not to repeat myself) it was better to focus on some things I didn’t enjoy 100% for a change; also if I mentioned everything I love about this series, the post would be far far too long! I wholly recommend the whole LOTR series to you all, as it’s completely epic (in both senses of the word) and I really can’t wait to watch the third film!